Should Your Daughter Join a Girl Scouts or Boy Scouts? 

Photo: H. Armstrong Roberts/Getty

The Boy Scouts will shortly acquire girls. It’s a divisive move—some see it as a long-fought feat for all a girls who’ve campaigned to get in over a years and were denied, while others see it as a rejecting of tradition, a Hail Mary try to accelerate a disappearing membership, or some grand ploy by “the left.” Regardless, girls who wish to join a scouting classification now have a choice.

So that should they choose? Despite common stereotypes of a dual groups, it’s not simply a matter of restraining knots contra offered cookies. Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts share a lot of identical values and activities, nonetheless they differ in some elemental ways. If you’re deliberation both for your daughter, here’s what we need to know about a dual organizations to assistance make your decision:

The Values

Here’s a Boy Scout Law:

A Scout is trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave, clean, and reverent.

This is a Girl Scout Law:

I will do my best to be Honest and Fair, Friendly and Helpful, Considerate and Caring, Courageous and Strong, and Responsible for what we contend and do, And to honour myself and others, honour authority, use resources wisely, make a universe a improved place, and be a sister to each Girl Scout.

FiveThirtyEight ran a consult to see that values complement was some-more in line with a values of Americans. The representation distance was small, though a formula showed that a normal percent of respondents rating a Girl Scout value as rather or unequivocally critical was 90 percent, and for Boy Scout values, it was 83 percent. Boy Scouts’ values of “obedient,” “thrifty” and “reverent” perceived a lowest scores.

Political Leanings

While Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts share identical start stories (both have roots with British ubiquitous Lord Baden-Powell), a dual organizations curve dramatically in their domestic leanings. The Girl Scouts have combined amicable probity to their mission; returned $100,000 from a donor who was opposite revelation transgender troops; featured distinguished LGBT rights activists as purpose models; and started revelation members they could reinstate “God” with whatever they believed in while reciting a Girl Scout Promise. Alternately, a Boy Scouts of America did not lift a anathema on plainly happy scouts until 2013, plainly happy director leaders until 2015, and transgender boys until progressing this year. BSA still bans atheists.


The Atlantic piece “Boy Scouts Are From Mars, Girl Scouts Are From Venus” summed adult a worldviews of a organizations like this:

“Boys, if they wish to learn how to tie slipknots and make fire, will do so in an atmosphere steeped in true masculine Christianity. Girls, if they wish to sell cookies and go camping, will soak adult messages about empowerment, diversity, and amicable activism.


Both a Boy Scouts and a Girl Scouts have programs for kids from kindergarten by 12th grade. For Girl Scouts, a member’s ranking is dynamic by her age and consequence badges, while Boy Scouts contingency accommodate with a director master to examination their progress, and seem before a house of examination before advancing to a subsequent level.


Every couple in America is different, and activities for both groups are mostly shabby by couple leaders, though both stress outside skills, village use activities, excursions and camping.

For Girl Scouts, a areas of concentration are:

  • Science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM). There are projects in mechanism programming, engineering and outside citizen science.
  • Outdoors
  • Life skills. Girl Scouts learn skills such as how to cope with bullying, how to launch a letter-writing campaign, and how to make intelligent shopping decisions.
  • Entrepreneurship. They learn business skills by offered cookies.

Boy Scouts attend in “skill challenges” such as walking with a compass, bandaging with neckerchief, pitching a tent, restraining knots and lashing. Popular activities embody a pinewood derby (Cub Scouts make derby cars and foe them in a competition), Jamboree-on-the-Air (an pledge radio eventuality that creates hit among Scouts from around a nation) and camporees (camps where infantry attend in rival events with other groups).


The Girl Scouts have their famed cookies, while Boy Scout infantry have no inhabitant fundraising item. Many Boy Scout councils sell popcorn, though some select to hawk poinsettas, carwashes, flags or chocolate bars.

Autonomy for Scout Leaders

Some relatives contend that Boy Scout leaders are given most some-more instruction than Girl Scout leaders. One mom, who was a Girl Scout leader, wrote this in a summary board:

That is indeed a two-sided coin—autonomy is good b/c we get to control how supports are spent and tailor it accurately to my girls’ badges, activities, interests, and plans. It can be bad, however, b/c my couple never had a advantage of being partial of a incomparable organisation (pack) and we was on my possess to “invent a wheel” or set adult a badge plan. we was on my possess to learn about camping and take a couple out (as a finish novice—having usually taken a training and never unequivocally started a glow but organisation of a trainer).

Co-Ed Versus an All-Girl Environment

Despite a news that girls will be authorised into Boy Scouts in 2018, some Girl Scout leaders have oral out to contend that a preference won’t impact their organization.

“What Girl Scouts offers can’t be replicated,” Girl Scouts of Northern New Jersey’s CEO Betty Garger told “Research shows that girls wish and flower in all-girl, girl-led, and girl-friendly environments where their specific needs are addressed, and we will continue to broach this.”

And if they don’t, they now have a choice to join a boys.

Short URL:

Posted by on Oct 12 2017. Filed under Gadgets. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply

Photo Gallery

Log in | Designed by hitechnews